What pure means in chemistry, how melting points show purity, what a formulation is, and how to run and read a paper chromatogram, including Rf values.
Objectives
Explain what a pure substance is in chemistry and use melting point data to tell pure substances from mixtures.
Say what a formulation is and recognise examples.
Describe how paper chromatography separates a mixture, and interpret a chromatogram.
Calculate an Rf value and use it to help identify a substance.
In everyday life "pure" means nothing has been added. In chemistry it means something stricter. This lesson is about telling pure substances from mixtures, and about a method called chromatography that separates coloured mixtures.
It matters because people need to know what is in their medicine, their food and their water. A chemist checks purity before a product is sold, and chromatography is one of the standard checks.
By the end you will be able to use melting point data, explain what a formulation is, run and read a chromatogram, and calculate an Rf value.
Pure or not?
In chemistry a pure substance is a single element or a single compound, not mixed with anything else. Orange juice from a carton might be called pure in a shop, but a chemist sees a mixture of water, sugars, acids and other substances.
Pure substances melt and boil at specific temperatures. Pure ice melts at 0 °C and pure water boils at 100 °C (at normal pressure). A mixture melts over a range of temperatures, and it usually starts to melt at a lower temperature than the pure substance.
So melting point data can show purity. A sharp melting point means the sample is pure. A melting range means there is something else in it.
Formulations
A formulation is a mixture that has been designed as a useful product. Each chemical in it has a job, and the amounts are measured carefully so that the product has the properties it needs.
Fuels, cleaning agents, paints, medicines, alloys, fertilisers and foods are all formulations. A paint, for example, has a pigment for the colour, a binder to make a hard film and a solvent so that it can be spread.
A formulation is not a pure substance. If you are given the label of a product that lists several ingredients in set amounts, you can say it is a formulation. You do not need to know the names of the chemicals in products sold under a brand name.
How chromatography works
Chromatography separates a mixture of soluble substances. In paper chromatography, a spot of the mixture is placed on a line near the bottom of a piece of paper. The paper stands in a solvent such as water. The solvent moves up the paper and carries the substances with it.
The paper is the stationary phase because it stays still. The solvent is the mobile phase because it moves. Each substance in the mixture spends its time between the two phases differently. A substance that dissolves well in the solvent travels far. A substance that sticks to the paper travels a short way.
So the substances spread out into separate spots. A pure substance gives one spot. A mixture can give several spots.
A flow of five steps for paper chromatography: draw a pencil line, put spots of the samples on the line, stand the paper in the solvent, remove it when the solvent reaches near the top, then dry it and measure the distances.
Setting up the practical
Draw the start line (the origin) in pencil about 1 cm from the bottom. Pencil is used because it does not dissolve in the solvent. An ink line would run up the paper with the solvent and spoil the results.
Put small spots of each sample on the line, with space between them, and let them dry. Stand the paper in a beaker with a shallow layer of solvent. The solvent level must be below the pencil line, or the spots would just dissolve into the beaker. Put a lid on the beaker to stop the solvent evaporating.
When the solvent is near the top, take the paper out and draw a line at the solvent front straight away, because it will evaporate. Let the paper dry. In the inks practical you can also use simple distillation to separate the water from the ink, so that you can see the solvent and the dyes separately.
Reading a chromatogram
Count the spots in each lane. One spot means a pure substance. Two or more spots mean a mixture. A mixture with three spots contains at least three substances.
To identify a substance, compare it with known substances run on the same paper. If a spot in your sample is at the same height and is the same colour as a known substance, they may be the same substance.
Under the same conditions a compound always travels the same fraction of the solvent distance. This fraction is the Rf value, so Rf values can be compared with reference tables.
Rf values
The Rf value is a ratio: Rf = distance moved by the substance ÷ distance moved by the solvent. Measure the substance distance from the start line to the centre of the spot. Measure the solvent distance from the start line to the solvent front.
Rf has no unit because the units cancel. It is always between 0 and 1. A substance that does not move has an Rf of 0. One that moves with the solvent has an Rf of 1. Quote it to 2 significant figures unless told otherwise.
Different compounds usually have different Rf values in the same solvent, so an Rf value helps to identify a compound. A different solvent gives different Rf values, so compare only like with like.
A formula triangle with the distance moved by the substance on top and Rf and the distance moved by the solvent along the bottom. Rf equals the substance distance divided by the solvent distance.
Recap
Pure means a single element or compound. Pure substances have sharp melting points. Mixtures melt over a range.
A formulation is a designed mixture with measured amounts, such as a paint or a medicine.
Chromatography separates soluble substances. Rf = distance moved by substance ÷ distance moved by solvent.
Key points
Pure = a single element or compound. Pure substances have sharp melting and boiling points.
A formulation is a designed mixture in measured amounts (paint, fuel, medicine, alloy, fertiliser, food).
Chromatography: paper = stationary phase, solvent = mobile phase. One spot = pure. More spots = mixture.
Rf = distance moved by substance ÷ distance moved by solvent. No unit, always between 0 and 1.
Worked examples
Example 1
A spot moves 3.0 cm up the paper. The solvent front moves 6.0 cm. Calculate the Rf value.
Rf = distance moved by substance ÷ distance moved by solvent.
Rf = 3.0 ÷ 6.0.
Rf = 0.50. It has no unit.
Answer: 0.50
Common slips
Slip: Rf = 6.0 ÷ 3.0 = 2.0 The ratio is substance over solvent. Rf cannot be more than 1.
Slip: Rf = 3.0 + 6.0 = 9.0 Rf is a division, not an addition.
Slip: Rf = 0.50 cm Rf has no unit.
Example 2
A sample gives two spots, at 2.4 cm and 5.6 cm from the start line. The solvent front is 8.0 cm from the start line. Calculate the Rf value of the spot that moved further, and say whether the sample is pure.
The spot that moved further is at 5.6 cm.
Rf = 5.6 ÷ 8.0 = 0.70.
There are two spots, so there are at least two substances.
The sample is a mixture, not pure.
Answer: Rf = 0.70. The sample is a mixture
Common slips
Slip: Rf = 8.0 ÷ 5.6 = 1.4 Use substance over solvent. The value must be between 0 and 1.
Slip: Rf = 2.4 ÷ 8.0 = 0.30 That is the Rf of the other spot. The question asks for the spot that moved further.
Slip: Pure, because the spots are clear. A pure substance gives one spot. Two spots mean a mixture.
Slip: Rf = 5.6 ÷ 2.4 = 2.3 Divide by the solvent distance, not the other spot.
Example 3
A student wants to find out whether a food colouring X contains dye A or dye B. Pure A has Rf 0.30 and pure B has Rf 0.55. In the same solvent, X gives spots with Rf 0.30 and 0.80. The solvent front moved 10.0 cm. Say what X contains, and how far the spot with Rf 0.80 moved.
A spot with Rf 0.30 matches dye A, so X contains A.
No spot has Rf 0.55, so dye B is not present.
The spot with Rf 0.80 matches neither dye, so X also contains another substance.
Distance moved = Rf × solvent distance = 0.80 × 10.0 = 8.0 cm.
Answer: X contains dye A and another substance. The 0.80 spot moved 8.0 cm
Common slips
Slip: X contains A and B. There is no spot at Rf 0.55, so B is not in X.
Slip: X contains only dye A. The 0.80 spot is a second substance, so X is a mixture.
Slip: The spot moved 12.5 cm. Multiply Rf by the solvent distance. 10.0 ÷ 0.80 divides the wrong way.
Slip: The spot moved 0.8 cm. Rf is a fraction of the solvent distance. 0.80 × 10.0 = 8.0 cm.
Questions and answers
Purity, formulations and chromatography practice questions for GCSE Combined Science Chemistry. Try each one, then open the answer. Easy questions come first.
Question 1 Easy
In paper chromatography, what name is given to the paper?
Show answer
Answer: stationary phase
The paper stays still.
It is the stationary phase.
Question 2 Easy
In paper chromatography, what name is given to the solvent?
Show answer
Answer: mobile phase
The solvent moves up the paper.
It is the mobile phase.
Question 3 Easy
Should the start line on chromatography paper be drawn in pencil or pen?
Show answer
Answer: pencil
Ink would dissolve and run.
Pencil does not dissolve.
Question 4 Easy
How many spots does a pure substance give on a chromatogram?
Show answer
Answer: one
A pure substance is a single substance.
It gives one spot.
Question 5 Easy
Rf equals the distance moved by the substance divided by the distance moved by what?
Show answer
Answer: the solvent
Rf compares the substance with the solvent.
Divide by the distance moved by the solvent.
Question 6 Medium
A spot moves 4.5 cm. The solvent front moves 9.0 cm. Calculate the Rf value.
Show answer
Answer: 0.50
Rf = distance moved by substance ÷ distance moved by solvent.
4.5 ÷ 9.0 = 0.50.
Question 7 Medium
A spot moves 3.0 cm. The solvent front moves 7.5 cm. Calculate the Rf value.
Show answer
Answer: 0.40
Rf = 3.0 ÷ 7.5.
Rf = 0.40.
Question 8 Medium
Does a pure substance melt at one sharp temperature or over a range of temperatures?
Show answer
Answer: one sharp temperature
Pure substances have specific melting points.
So it melts at one sharp temperature.
Exam-style questions
Longer questions in the style of a written paper, with the marking points. These are Yumio practice questions.
Exam-style question 14 marks
(a) A bottle of orange juice is labelled "pure orange juice". Explain why a chemist would say it is not pure. [2 marks] (b) Describe how melting point data can show that a solid is pure. [2 marks]
Show answer and marking points
Answer: (a) orange juice is a mixture of several substances, but a pure substance is a single element or compound (b) a pure solid melts at one sharp temperature, but an impure solid melts over a range of temperatures
(a) it is a mixture or contains more than one substance (1)
(a) a pure substance is a single element or compound (1)
(b) a pure solid has a sharp (specific) melting point (1)
(b) an impure solid melts over a range (1)
Exam-style question 25 marks
A student runs a chromatogram. The solvent front moves 10.0 cm. Dye A moves 3.0 cm, dye B moves 5.0 cm and dye C moves 7.5 cm. Sample X gives two spots, at 3.0 cm and 7.5 cm. (a) Calculate the Rf value of dye A. [2 marks] (b) Which dyes are in sample X? [1 mark] (c) Explain why the start line is drawn in pencil. [1 mark] (d) Explain how the chromatogram shows that X is a mixture. [1 mark]
Show answer and marking points
Answer: (a) 0.30 (b) A and C (c) pencil does not dissolve in the solvent, but ink would run (d) there are two spots, so more than one substance
(a) 3.0 ÷ 10.0 (1)
(a) 0.30 (1)
(b) A and C (1)
(c) pencil does not dissolve or run in the solvent (1)
(d) two spots or more than one spot (1)
Common mistakes
Using an ink pen for the start line
Use pencil. Ink dissolves and runs up the paper with the solvent.
Putting the start line under the solvent
The solvent level must be below the pencil line, or the spots dissolve into the beaker.
Working out Rf the wrong way up
Rf = distance moved by substance ÷ distance moved by solvent. It is never more than 1.
Measuring to the edge of the spot
Measure from the start line to the centre of the spot.
Saying a mixture has a sharp melting point
A pure substance has a sharp melting point. A mixture melts over a range.
Questions students ask
Is Purity, formulations and chromatography on the Foundation or Higher tier?
Purity, formulations and chromatography is on both Foundation and Higher papers for GCSE Combined Science Chemistry, aimed at around grade 4.
What is a common mistake on Purity, formulations and chromatography?
Using an ink pen for the start line. Use pencil. Ink dissolves and runs up the paper with the solvent.
Where are the answers to the Purity, formulations and chromatography questions?
Open Show answer under each question on this page. The questions are Yumio practice questions, not past exam questions.