Antibiotics, painkillers and drug testing explained
Start here
Drugs are chemicals that change how your body works. Doctors use them to treat illness. This lesson is about antibiotics, painkillers, and how a new drug is tested before anyone is allowed to take it.
It matters because antibiotics are some of the most useful medicines we have, and bacteria are learning to resist them. It also matters because you should be able to judge whether a drug trial is fair.
By the end you will be able to explain why antibiotics do not work on every illness. You will explain antibiotic resistance. You will also describe how drugs are tested and why placebos are used.
Antibiotics and painkillers
Antibiotics, such as penicillin, kill bacteria or stop them growing. Bacteria are tiny living cells that can cause infections. Different bacteria need different antibiotics, so a doctor picks the right one.
Antibiotics do not work on viruses. A virus lives inside your own cells, so it is hard to kill it without harming the cell. A cold is caused by a virus.
Painkillers are different. They relieve symptoms such as pain. They do not kill the pathogen, which is the microbe causing the disease.
How resistance starts
Bacteria can change by chance. A change in a gene is called a mutation. Sometimes a mutation makes a bacterium resistant, which means an antibiotic can no longer kill it.
Now think about a patient taking the antibiotic. It kills most of the bacteria, but the resistant ones survive. They reproduce, so there are more of them each time.
Soon most of the bacteria in the population are resistant. This is natural selection. MRSA is a bacterium resistant to many antibiotics. It is a serious risk in hospitals.
Slowing resistance down
We cannot stop mutations, but we can slow the spread of resistance. Doctors should not prescribe antibiotics for viral infections or very mild infections.
Patients should finish the whole course, even if they feel better. This kills all the bacteria, so fewer resistant ones are left to multiply.
Farmers should use fewer antibiotics on animals. New antibiotics are being developed, but this is slow. So we must use the ones we have with care. Otherwise, common infections could become dangerous again.
Where drugs come from
Many drugs were first found in plants and microorganisms. Microorganisms are living things too small to see without a microscope. Mould is one example.
Digitalis comes from the foxglove plant and is used to treat heart conditions. Aspirin was first made from a chemical in willow bark. It is a painkiller. Penicillin was found by Alexander Fleming, from the mould Penicillium.
Today most new drugs are made by chemists in laboratories. Scientists still study plants, because their chemicals might become new medicines.
Testing a new drug
New drugs are tested for safety, side effects and efficacy. Efficacy just means whether the drug works. This testing happens in stages, so people are not put at risk.
First the drug is tested on cells and tissues in a lab. Then it is tested on live animals. Next come clinical trials, which are tests on people.
A small trial on healthy volunteers uses a low dose to check safety. Then patients take part, to find the best dose and see if it works. Other scientists check the results before they are published. This is called peer review.
A flow of drug testing stages: cells and tissues, then live animals, then healthy volunteers, then patients.
Placebos and double-blind trials
In a trial, some patients get the new drug. Others get a placebo, which is a tablet that looks the same but has no active drug in it.
The placebo group shows how much people improve just because they expect to. Without it, we could not tell if the drug really works. Think of a taste test where you do not know which crisps are which brand.
In a double-blind trial, neither the patients nor the doctors know who got which until the end. This stops bias. Larger trials give more reliable results.
Recap
Antibiotics kill bacteria but not viruses. Painkillers treat symptoms only.
Resistance starts with a chance mutation, and then natural selection makes it common. Finish your course of antibiotics.
Digitalis comes from foxglove, aspirin from willow bark and penicillin from a mould.
Drugs are tested on cells, animals, healthy volunteers, then patients. Placebos and double-blind trials keep the test fair.
Key points
Antibiotics kill bacteria and do not work on viruses. Painkillers treat symptoms only.
Resistance arises by mutation and natural selection.
Drugs: digitalis from foxglove, aspirin from willow, penicillin from a mould.
Trials: cells, animals, healthy volunteers, patients, with placebos and double-blind testing.
Worked examples
Example 1
Name the plant that is the source of the heart drug digitalis.
Many drugs come from plants.
Digitalis is a heart drug.
It comes from the foxglove.
Answer: foxglove
Common slips
Slip: willow Willow bark gave us aspirin.
Slip: Penicillium This is a mould that gave us penicillin.
Slip: mint Mint is not the source of digitalis.
Example 2
Explain why a doctor does not prescribe antibiotics for a cold.
A cold is caused by a virus.
Antibiotics do not kill viruses.
Using them unnecessarily also increases the chance of resistant bacteria.
Answer: A cold is caused by a virus and antibiotics only kill bacteria
Common slips
Slip: A cold is a bacterial infection. Colds are viral.
Slip: Antibiotics make colds worse. The problem is that they do not work on viruses.
Slip: Antibiotics are too expensive. The main reasons are that they do not work and cause resistance.
Example 3
A trial of a new drug uses 500 patients. Half get the drug and half get a placebo. Neither the patients nor the doctors know who gets which. Explain why the trial is designed like this.
The placebo group shows what happens without the drug.
Double-blind testing means the patients and doctors do not know who has the drug, so they cannot be biased.
A large group makes the results more reliable.
Answer: A placebo is a control for comparison, double-blind removes bias, and large numbers make results reliable
Common slips
Slip: The placebo makes the drug stronger. The placebo has no effect on the drug.
Slip: The doctors know so they can adjust the dose. In a double-blind trial they do not know.
Slip: The sample size does not matter. Larger samples are more reliable.
Questions and answers
Antibiotics, painkillers and drug testing practice questions for GCSE Combined Science Biology. Try each one, then open the answer. Easy questions come first.
Question 1 Easy
Name the type of pathogen that antibiotics kill.
Show answer
Answer: bacteria
Antibiotics work on cells.
They kill bacteria.
Question 2 Easy
From which plant does the heart drug digitalis come?
Show answer
Answer: foxglove
A tall plant gave the drug.
It is the foxglove.
Question 3 Easy
Which tree bark was the first source of aspirin?
Show answer
Answer: willow
It was used to ease pain.
It is willow.
Question 4 Easy
What word describes a tablet with no active drug used in a trial?
Show answer
Answer: placebo
It looks like the drug.
It is a placebo.
Question 5 Easy
What word describes a bacterium that an antibiotic can no longer kill?
Show answer
Answer: resistant
The antibiotic does not work on it.
The bacterium is resistant.
Question 6 Easy
Name the type of pathogen that causes a cold.
Show answer
Answer: virus
A cold is not caused by bacteria.
It is caused by a virus.
Question 7 Medium
Who discovered penicillin?
Show answer
Answer: Alexander Fleming
He noticed a mould killing bacteria.
It was Fleming.
Question 8 Medium
Name the bacterium that is resistant to many antibiotics and found in hospitals.
Show answer
Answer: MRSA
It is a resistant strain.
It is MRSA.
Exam-style questions
Longer questions in the style of a written paper, with the marking points. These are Yumio practice questions.
Exam-style question 14 marks
(a) Explain why antibiotics are not used to treat influenza. [1 mark] (b) Explain how antibiotic-resistant bacteria can become common. [3 marks]
Show answer and marking points
Answer: (a) influenza is caused by a virus and antibiotics do not kill viruses (b) a mutation makes some bacteria resistant, the antibiotic kills the non-resistant bacteria, and the resistant bacteria survive and reproduce, passing on resistance
(a) influenza is caused by a virus, which antibiotics do not kill (1)
(b) a mutation produces resistant bacteria (1)
(b) non-resistant bacteria are killed by the antibiotic (1)
(b) resistant bacteria survive, reproduce and pass on resistance (1)
Exam-style question 24 marks
Describe how a new drug is tested before it can be used, and explain why a placebo is used. [4 marks]
Show answer and marking points
Answer: The drug is tested on cells and tissues, then on live animals, then in clinical trials on healthy volunteers and on patients. Some patients are given a placebo so that the effect of the drug can be compared and expectation does not affect the result.
tested on cells or tissues in the lab, then live animals (1)
clinical trial on healthy volunteers to check safety, with a low dose (1)
then tested on patients to check it works and find the dose (1)
a placebo is used to compare, so the effect is not due to expectation (1)
Common mistakes
Saying antibiotics kill viruses
Antibiotics kill only bacteria.
Saying bacteria become resistant because they want to
Resistance appears by random mutation, and then natural selection makes it common.
Saying a placebo is a different drug
A placebo has no active ingredient.
Stopping a course of antibiotics when you feel better
Finish the course so all the bacteria are killed.
Questions students ask
Is Antibiotics, painkillers and drug testing on the Foundation or Higher tier?
Antibiotics, painkillers and drug testing is on both Foundation and Higher papers for GCSE Combined Science Biology, aimed at around grade 6.
What is a common mistake on Antibiotics, painkillers and drug testing?
Saying antibiotics kill viruses. Antibiotics kill only bacteria.
Where are the answers to the Antibiotics, painkillers and drug testing questions?
Open Show answer under each question on this page. The questions are Yumio practice questions, not past exam questions.